Uploaded image for project: 'MusicBrainz Server'
  1. MusicBrainz Server
  2. MBS-9754

Make it possible to add ISRCs to tracks

XMLWordPrintable

    • Icon: Improvement Improvement
    • Resolution: Unresolved
    • Icon: Normal Normal
    • None
    • None
    • Editing interface
    • None

      Currently ISRCs are tied to recordings. When we look at a recording page, we don't know which releases the ISRCs came from. This needlessly complicates recording management.

      One solution is to attach ISRCs to tracks. Recordings can inherit the ISRCs from tracks so the recording entities will not lose any information. We don't even need to remove the possibility to add ISRCs directly to recordings if we don't want to. Recording pages could look almost identical to what they look now but there would be an ISRC column with an ISRC field for each track.

      For the actual ISRC addition, an editor described in MBS-3872 would be nice.

        1. example_mockup.png
          example_mockup.png
          86 kB

          [MBS-9754] Make it possible to add ISRCs to tracks

          phonebox made changes -
          Description Original: Currently ISRCs are tied to recordings. When we look at a recording page, we don't know which releases the ISRCs came from. This needlessly complicates recording management.

          The solution is to attach ISRCs to tracks. Recordings can inherit the ISRCs from tracks so the recording entities will not lose any information. We don't even need to remove the possibility to add ISRCs directly to recordings if we don't want to. Recording pages could look almost identical to what they look now but there would be an ISRC column with an ISRC field for each track.

          For the actual ISRC addition, an editor described in MBS-3872 would be nice.           		New: Currently ISRCs are tied to recordings. When we look at a recording page, we don't know which releases the ISRCs came from. This needlessly complicates recording management.

          _One_ solution is to attach ISRCs to tracks. Recordings can inherit the ISRCs from tracks so the recording entities will not lose any information. We don't even need to remove the possibility to add ISRCs directly to recordings if we don't want to. Recording pages could look almost identical to what they look now but there would be an ISRC column with an ISRC field for each track.

          For the actual ISRC addition, an editor described in MBS-3872 would be nice.
          yvanzo made changes -
          Link New: This issue is related to MBS-8907 [ MBS-8907 ]
          phonebox made changes -
          Attachment New: example_mockup.png [ 12118 ]
          phonebox made changes -
          Description Original: Currently ISRCs are tied to recordings. When we look at a recording page, we don't know which releases the ISRCs came from. This needlessly complicates recording management.

          The solution is to attach ISRCs to tracks. Recordings can inherit the ISRCs from tracks so the recording entities will not lose any information. We don't even need to remove the possibility to add ISRCs directly to recordings if we don't want to. Recording pages could look identical to what they look now but there would be an ISRC column.

          For the actual ISRC addition, an editor described in MBS-3872 would be nice.           		New: Currently ISRCs are tied to recordings. When we look at a recording page, we don't know which releases the ISRCs came from. This needlessly complicates recording management.

          The solution is to attach ISRCs to tracks. Recordings can inherit the ISRCs from tracks so the recording entities will not lose any information. We don't even need to remove the possibility to add ISRCs directly to recordings if we don't want to. Recording pages could look almost identical to what they look now but there would be an ISRC column with an ISRC field for each track.

          For the actual ISRC addition, an editor described in MBS-3872 would be nice.
          phonebox made changes -
          Component/s New: Editing interface [ 10101 ]
          phonebox made changes -
          Link New: This issue is related to MBS-3872 [ MBS-3872 ]
          phonebox made changes -
          Description Original: Currently ISRCs are tied to recordings. When we look at a recording page, we don't know which releases the ISRCs came from. This needlessly complicates recording management.

          The solution is to attach ISRCs to tracks. Recordings can inherit the ISRCs from tracks so the recording entities will not lose any information. We don't even need to remove the possibility to add ISRCs directly to recordings if we don't want to. Recording pages could look identical to what they looks now but there would be an ISRC column.

          For the actual ISRC addition, an editor described in MBS-3872 would be nice.           		New: Currently ISRCs are tied to recordings. When we look at a recording page, we don't know which releases the ISRCs came from. This needlessly complicates recording management.

          The solution is to attach ISRCs to tracks. Recordings can inherit the ISRCs from tracks so the recording entities will not lose any information. We don't even need to remove the possibility to add ISRCs directly to recordings if we don't want to. Recording pages could look identical to what they look now but there would be an ISRC column.

          For the actual ISRC addition, an editor described in MBS-3872 would be nice.
          phonebox created issue -

            Unassigned Unassigned
            phonebox phonebox
            Votes:
            15 Vote for this issue
            Watchers:
            12 Start watching this issue

              Created:
              Updated:

                Version Package