-
Improvement
-
Resolution: Unresolved
-
Normal
-
None
-
None
-
None
They are less stable and adding them or replacing the channel ID ones by them should be discouraged.
https://chatlogs.metabrainz.org/brainzbot/musicbrainz/msg/4596074/
Google makes it pretty clear that they are not stable and can even be reused by others.
It turns out that shortening a custom URL by removing “/c” is contrary to documentation not guaranteed to work in all cases, see MBS-11997
Custom channel URLs also make it harder to programmatically use them, e,g. downstream data users, editing bots, or duplicate detection:
- https://developers.google.com/youtube/v3/docs/channels
- https://developers.google.com/youtube/v3/guides/working_with_channel_ids
Furthermore it seems that channels can have multiple branded URLs:
- edit 70397272 https://www.youtube.com/KingNae
- edit 70330322 https://www.youtube.com/NaeOfficialkingnae
Both of them have the same canonical channel ID UCxLCxSB1v8k3Rk0-HIz0OGg:
<link rel="canonical" href="https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCxLCxSB1v8k3Rk0-HIz0OGg">
A few examples where YouTube links are replaced in either direction:
- edit 69574466
- edit 69535828
- edit 69491242
- edit 69386197
- edit 69305504
- edit 69273909
- edit 69171477 (old custom URL doesn't work as of now)
- edit 69137765
- edit 69023049
- edit 68901823
- edit 68842473
- edit 68554513
- edit 68497369
- edit 68497368
- edit 68456125
- edit 68431601
- edit 68386966
- edit 68313182
- edit 68168182
- edit 68163935
- edit 68105961 (old custom URL doesn't work as of now)
- edit 67984794
- edit 66988675 (I remember the old custom URL didn't work when they removed it but now it does)
- edit 67935147
- edit 67823286
- edit 67620447
- edit 70053601
- edit 69760037
- edit 69753187
- edit 70080516 (admits it's for marketing)
- edit 72516055
- edit 78842472 (URL returned by search)
- edit 79957050 (channel ID was already in use, someone changed to custom one and just a week later it broke)
- edit 94028143 (channel ID was changed to handle, a few months later handle was changed and URL broke)