-
Type:
Improvement
-
Resolution: Won't Do
-
Priority:
Normal
-
None
-
Affects Version/s: None
-
Component/s: Guidelines
-
None
I propose using the keyboard-accessible ASCII characters -, ', and " instead of typographic punctuation such as ‐, ’, and “ ” in artist, release, and recording names.
This proposal concerns punctuation only. Non-ASCII letters (é, ö, ñ, 日本語, etc.) would remain unchanged.
Reasons:
- Better compatibility with the rest of the music ecosystem (Spotify, Apple Music, Discogs, Bandcamp, Tidal, Qobuz, etc.).
- Reduces duplicate entries such as Static-X and Static‐X, which many users cannot distinguish.
- Reduces unnecessary edits in the MB
- Works more reliably with older hardware, software, and media players.
- Can be typed directly on virtually every keyboard without special input methods.
- The visual difference is minimal, while the interoperability benefits are significant.
MusicBrainz is a metadata source used by many applications and devices. Using common ASCII punctuation would reduce friction while preserving support for all languages through Unicode letters where needed.