• Icon: New Feature New Feature
    • Resolution: Unresolved
    • Icon: Normal Normal
    • Historical
    • None

      Please add South Vietnam as a historical area (similar to how we have East Germany).

       

      https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/South_Vietnam

       

      I just ran into this while adding some labels and releases, e.g. see these South Vietnamese labels https://www.discogs.com/label/212737-S%C3%B3ng-Nh%E1%BA%A1c?page=1  https://www.discogs.com/label/900326-T%C3%A2n-Thanh?page=1

          [AREQ-3317] South Vietnam

          There's a few historical areas that were grandfathered in because they were in the original list we used for release countries (this, the Soviet Union, Yugoslavia, a couple more). But yeah, adding new ones is not something we have generally done. I could see adding this one though as it was an actual country and has actual releases, which is true of a fairly small amount of historical areas and might be a better reason than just "someone was born in this no-longer-existing place".

          Nicolás Tamargo added a comment - There's a few historical areas that were grandfathered in because they were in the original list we used for release countries (this, the Soviet Union, Yugoslavia, a couple more). But yeah, adding new ones is not something we have generally done. I could see adding this one though as it was an actual country and has actual releases, which is true of a fairly small amount of historical areas and might be a better reason than just "someone was born in this no-longer-existing place".

          dr saunders added a comment -

          You are talking about adding a country to the country list we use for labels. That is a different list than for Areas.

          Historical Area is out of scope for what we want for Areas, the history of all the towns and cities, would be very messy, so we don't do historical, we use what the area is today. This isn't an areas database.

          dr saunders added a comment - You are talking about adding a country to the country list we use for labels. That is a different list than for Areas. Historical Area is out of scope for what we want for Areas, the history of all the towns and cities, would be very messy, so we don't do historical, we use what the area is today. This isn't an areas database.

          fdsa__ added a comment -

          Would appreciate some clarification on "we don't do", considering that apparently historically we did.

           

          https://musicbrainz.org/area/d907b0ac-2956-386f-a246-62d55779aae1

          https://musicbrainz.org/search?query=ended%3Atrue&type=area&limit=100&method=advanced

          fdsa__ added a comment - Would appreciate some clarification on "we don't do", considering that apparently historically we did.   https://musicbrainz.org/area/d907b0ac-2956-386f-a246-62d55779aae1 https://musicbrainz.org/search?query=ended%3Atrue&type=area&limit=100&method=advanced

          dr saunders added a comment -

          this one is a won't do for me. we don't do historical for areas

          reassinging to reosarevok as its a country, so it could be added there, but i'll imagine this will be a wont fix for him as well

          dr saunders added a comment - this one is a won't do for me. we don't do historical for areas reassinging to reosarevok as its a country, so it could be added there, but i'll imagine this will be a wont fix for him as well

            reosarevok Nicolás Tamargo
            fdsa__ fdsa__
            Votes:
            0 Vote for this issue
            Watchers:
            3 Start watching this issue

              Created:
              Updated:

                Version Package