ocharles' comments from http://codereview.musicbrainz.org/r/1110/ :
From testing it on test.mb here are my observations from a UI perspective:
- The "manual entry" tab is confusing. It has text explaining other tabs inside that tab, which I find a little a strange. I think this might be better suited as a separate "add a new disc" button within the dialog.
With the other tabs:
- The tab order is weird - it goes release -> artist -> search button -> tracklist count.
- The tracklists don't have alternating row styling - I think it would be good to be consistent here if we can
- It's really confusing that expanding a tracklist is how you select it. At first I thought this was just a way to preview it, but then I couldn't work out how I was meant to select it. I just took a guess which thankfully did work
If I click add disc the dialog doesn't appear screen centered. For example, if I already have a few discs and I click the button at the bottom of the page, the dialog appears at the top of the page.