Uploaded image for project: 'MusicBrainz Server'
  1. MusicBrainz Server
  2. MBS-2239

Newly created work does not appear on the author's list of works

        [MBS-2239] Newly created work does not appear on the author's list of works

        Oliver Charles added a comment - http://tickets.musicbrainz.org/browse/MBS-341

        Thank you for the information. Certainly there must be a ticket for the problem if this one has been closed.

        Václav Brožík added a comment - Thank you for the information. Certainly there must be a ticket for the problem if this one has been closed.

        Oh right, OK. That's terribly confusing, yeah. Where's the ticket for the enhancement to this?

        voiceinsideyou added a comment - Oh right, OK. That's terribly confusing, yeah. Where's the ticket for the enhancement to this?

        Ok, this is actually not a bug at all - http://musicbrainz.org/artist/819eaeb2-8dd8-48a5-ad07-0bcd137985ef/works?page=55 shows the work. The way the works display works is it first shows all works where the artist is a performer on a recording for that work, and then, it shows works where the artist has a direct AR to the work, split into the type of AR. You can see this split more in the last page - http://musicbrainz.org/artist/819eaeb2-8dd8-48a5-ad07-0bcd137985ef/works?page=71.

        I think this ticket is really about how bad the pagination system is, but we're aware of that and we will have something considerably more usable in the near future.

        Oliver Charles added a comment - Ok, this is actually not a bug at all - http://musicbrainz.org/artist/819eaeb2-8dd8-48a5-ad07-0bcd137985ef/works?page=55 shows the work. The way the works display works is it first shows all works where the artist is a performer on a recording for that work, and then , it shows works where the artist has a direct AR to the work, split into the type of AR. You can see this split more in the last page - http://musicbrainz.org/artist/819eaeb2-8dd8-48a5-ad07-0bcd137985ef/works?page=71 . I think this ticket is really about how bad the pagination system is, but we're aware of that and we will have something considerably more usable in the near future.

        Oh, I've actually noticed my comment here is actually for MBS-2294. This is about the works tab, not editing linking as I initially read it wrong. The works displayed in the 'works' tab are works that the artist has a direct relationship too (artist-work ARs), and also artists in the artist credits of the "top" recordings for a work, where top is defined to be the 3 recordings with the most aggregate ARs.

        Oliver Charles added a comment - Oh, I've actually noticed my comment here is actually for MBS-2294 . This is about the works tab, not editing linking as I initially read it wrong. The works displayed in the 'works' tab are works that the artist has a direct relationship too (artist-work ARs), and also artists in the artist credits of the "top" recordings for a work, where top is defined to be the 3 recordings with the most aggregate ARs.

        Oh, okay - so similar to MBS-2294.

        What's the current logic determining what is displayed on that page? (I'm sure to need to explain this to other people; not quite sure (same as Václav) what makes the works appear that are currently appearing...)

        voiceinsideyou added a comment - Oh, okay - so similar to MBS-2294 . What's the current logic determining what is displayed on that page? (I'm sure to need to explain this to other people; not quite sure (same as Václav) what makes the works appear that are currently appearing...)

        We need to decide how the linking will occur. Does it link to all artists that a work is linked to? Does it link to only certain types of artists (composer, etc)? Does it link to artists in linked recording artist credits - that is, the artists who performed a recording of a work?

        Oliver Charles added a comment - We need to decide how the linking will occur. Does it link to all artists that a work is linked to? Does it link to only certain types of artists (composer, etc)? Does it link to artists in linked recording artist credits - that is, the artists who performed a recording of a work?

        Can you please detail what that discussion required is?

        voiceinsideyou added a comment - Can you please detail what that discussion required is?

        Needs more discussion, will have to wait

        Oliver Charles added a comment - Needs more discussion, will have to wait

        The name change of the work has already taken effect so the current name is: Symfonie č. 9 e moll, op. 95 „Z Nového světa".
        http://musicbrainz.org/work/aacb1ab0-c740-436a-a782-ed60026cf82b

        I checked the list on the composer's Works tab again and the work is not listed there:
        http://musicbrainz.org/artist/819eaeb2-8dd8-48a5-ad07-0bcd137985ef/works?page=20

        I do not understand what makes the works to appear on the author's Works tab.

        Václav Brožík added a comment - The name change of the work has already taken effect so the current name is: Symfonie č. 9 e moll, op. 95 „Z Nového světa". http://musicbrainz.org/work/aacb1ab0-c740-436a-a782-ed60026cf82b I checked the list on the composer's Works tab again and the work is not listed there: http://musicbrainz.org/artist/819eaeb2-8dd8-48a5-ad07-0bcd137985ef/works?page=20 I do not understand what makes the works to appear on the author's Works tab.

          acid2 Oliver Charles
          pabouk Václav Brožík
          Votes:
          0 Vote for this issue
          Watchers:
          1 Start watching this issue

            Created:
            Updated:
            Resolved:

              Version Package
              Bug fixes, 2011-06-01