Uploaded image for project: 'MetaBrainz'
  1. MetaBrainz
  2. MEB-161

Missing date of release in recording results

    • Icon: Bug Bug
    • Resolution: Unresolved
    • Icon: Normal Normal
    • None
    • None
    • None
    • None

      Howdy!

      I don't know if I should include everythjng from the thread that lead me to create this ticket:

      https://community.metabrainz.org/t/is-a-missing-release-status-a-data-error/694045

      Basically I am writing a toll to create NFO files for Kodi's music videos library. I decided it was best to capture both the single and the album. When rewriting my code I came across a problem with Lionel Richie's "Dancing on the Ceiling" where the single has no date yet the actual MusicBrainz page does.

      `https://musicbrainz.org/ws/2/recording?query=%22dancing+on_the_ceiling%22%20AND%20artist:%22lionel+richie%22&limit=100&fmt=json`

      returns in part:

      ```

      {     "id": "c8c017c8-85ff-4bd5-b67a-5bc2eedb0c11",     "score": 67,     "title": "Dancin' on the Ceiling",     "length": 262000,     "video": null,     "artist-credit": [...],     "first-release-date": "1986",     "releases": [         \{...}

      ,
              {
                  "id": "3cb2f7af-1aa8-40fd-98a6-c09ea07256ba",
                  "count": 1,
                  "title": "Dancing on the Ceiling",
                  "artist-credit": [
                      {
                          "name": "Lionel Richie",
                          "artist":

      {                         "id": "3cb25fb2-5547-4b05-adec-1a5e37830d46",                         "name": "Lionel Richie",                         "sort-name": "Richie, Lionel"                     }

                      }
                  ],
                  "release-group":

      {                 "id": "3d79a50c-c480-4dff-8625-ce7164946e8b",                 "type-id": "d6038452-8ee0-3f68-affc-2de9a1ede0b9",                 "primary-type-id": "d6038452-8ee0-3f68-affc-2de9a1ede0b9",                 "title": "Dancing on the Ceiling",                 "primary-type": "Single"             }

      ,
                  "track-count": 2,
                  "media": [
                      {
                          "position": 1,
                          "format": "7\" Vinyl",
                          "track": [
                             

      {                             "id": "914b1970-ed6e-4244-8400-ec0d6ebfd56b",                             "number": "1",                             "title": "Dancing on the Ceiling",                             "length": 260000                         }

                          ],
                          "track-count": 2,
                          "track-offset": 0
                      }
                  ]
              },
              {
                  "id": "a8d62085-4c40-4b34-8f08-63f644e79d0d",
                  "status-id": "4e304316-386d-3409-af2e-78857eec5cfe",
                  "count": 1,
                  "title": "Back to Front",
                  "status": "Official",
                  "artist-credit": [
                      {
                          "name": "Lionel Richie",
                          "artist":

      {                         "id": "3cb25fb2-5547-4b05-adec-1a5e37830d46",                         "name": "Lionel Richie",                         "sort-name": "Richie, Lionel"                     }

                      }
                  ],
                  "release-group":

      {                 "id": "6e3be147-2bd7-342c-9c04-5ed7c32ddf1e",                 "type-id": "dd2a21e1-0c00-3729-a7a0-de60b84eb5d1",                 "primary-type-id": "f529b476-6e62-324f-b0aa-1f3e33d313fc",                 "title": "Back to Front",                 "primary-type": "Album",                 "secondary-types": [                     "Compilation"                 ],                 "secondary-type-ids": [                     "dd2a21e1-0c00-3729-a7a0-de60b84eb5d1"                 ]             }

      ,
                  "date": "1992",
                  "country": "AU",
                  "release-events": [
                      {
                          "date": "1992",
                          "area":

      {                         "id": "106e0bec-b638-3b37-b731-f53d507dc00e",                         "name": "Australia",                         "sort-name": "Australia",                         "iso-3166-1-codes": [                             "AU"                         ]                     }

                      }
                  ],
                  "track-count": 16,
                  "media": [
                      {
                          "position": 1,
                          "format": "CD",
                          "track": [
                             

      {                             "id": "af88b0d3-e6ca-47aa-bf33-f13e542e0c85",                             "number": "9",                             "title": "Dancin' on the Ceiling",                             "length": 262600                         }

                          ],
                          "track-count": 16,
                          "track-offset": 8
                      }
                  ]
              },
              {}
          ]
      }
      ```

      The associated `release-group` shows a date:

      https://musicbrainz.org/release-group/3d79a50c-c480-4dff-8625-ce7164946e8b

      A call to the `release-group`

      `https://musicbrainz.org/ws/2/release-group/3d79a50c-c480-4dff-8625-ce7164946e8b?fmt=json`

      returns:

      ```

      { "title": "Dancing on the Ceiling", "secondary-type-ids": [], "primary-type-id": "d6038452-8ee0-3f68-affc-2de9a1ede0b9", "first-release-date": "1986", "primary-type": "Single", "disambiguation": "", "secondary-types": [], "id": "3d79a50c-c480-4dff-8625-ce7164946e8b" }

      ```

      A call to the `release`

      `https://musicbrainz.org/ws/2/release/3cb2f7af-1aa8-40fd-98a6-c09ea07256ba?fmt=json`

      returns:

      ```
      {
          "country": null,
          "cover-art-archive":

      {         "count": 1,         "front": false,         "back": false,         "darkened": false,         "artwork": true     }

      ,
          "text-representation":

      {         "script": null,         "language": null     }

      ,
          "status": null,
          "release-events": [
             

      {             "date": "1986",             "area": null         }

          ],
          "barcode": null,
          "status-id": null,
          "id": "3cb2f7af-1aa8-40fd-98a6-c09ea07256ba",
          "quality": "normal",
          "asin": null,
          "disambiguation": "",
          "title": "Dancing on the Ceiling",
          "packaging": "Cardboard/Paper Sleeve",
          "packaging-id": "f7101ce3-0384-39ce-9fde-fbbd0044d35f",
          "date": "1986"
      }
      ```
      So the data is there just not coming in the `recording` call. I have tested plenty of others and none have been missing this date on the ones I've checked.

       Thanks!
      Chris

            Unassigned Unassigned
            clubside clubside
            Votes:
            0 Vote for this issue
            Watchers:
            1 Start watching this issue

              Created:
              Updated:

                Version Package