-
Improvement
-
Resolution: Fixed
-
Normal
-
None
-
None
Import of http://bugs.musicbrainz.org/ticket/3683
The idea is to address the all too common situation when you have just added a new release but are too late spot a typo. I propose we allow edits that fit the following criteria be applied immediately as auto-edits:
1) The editor altering the data is the same one who added the release. 2) The subsequent edits are within a specific short timeframe 3) The subsequent edits are changing existing data (alterations to style fixes to titles, time corrections, status changes, language/script, release info) not removing or adding.
This would alleviate some minor but common situations: a) The fact that when you are voting on only 'add release' edits (apparently a pretty common scenario) you don't see the additional later edits correcting small issues. It's common to see 'Yes but....' with a small nit pointed out in edit notes, only to be followed up with 'I already fixed that'. b) That auto editors sometimes clobber those later edits with autoedits without meaning to because of a)
And just that it's really easy to accidentally miss small issues and have to create several edits to fix them, when if you'd noticed them during the add release, they wouldn't be separate edits.
Suggested timeframes from the mailing list thread included: 30 minutes, an hour, until next time modbot runs, until the add release edit has had a comment, or until the add release edit has had a vote [note from reosarevok: I like this one], or alternatively don't allow votes until the short autoapprove period is up.
Original discussion: http://musicbrainz.1054305.n4.nabble.com/A-cute-idea-td1086837.html
- has related issue
-
MBS-9650 Editing recording that was added by release addition within 1 day should be auto
- Open
-
MBS-8647 "Edits for subscribed entites" doesn't show auto-edits
- Closed
-
MBS-8905 Editing release events in a 1 hour delay should be auto
- Closed
-
MBS-8927 Lowering release data quality in a 1 hour delay should be auto
- Closed
-
MBS-10231 Increase time span applying edits after adding a release without requiring votes
- Open
-
MBS-11649 Make changes to recordings created by new release auto-edits as well
- Open
-
MBS-13466 Auto approve merge for new artist, release etc.
- Open
-
MBS-6481 show changes immediately while edits are pending
- Closed
-
MBS-8134 Allow unreviewed edits on new entries for a period of time
- Closed
-
MBS-9505 Extend time period to edit your own entries to 1 day
- Closed
- is duplicated by
-
MBS-5769 inmediately apply edits to my own contributions
- Closed
- resolves
-
MBS-2480 Add option to modify an edit
- Closed